Every Requirement Gets a Verdict. I Had Been Reviewing Without One.

You merge the PR. The build passes. The code does what you expected it to do. You move on. That is review for most engineers. A final read. A feeling that things looked right before the branch closed. I did it the same way for years. Three phases had already run before this one. Think had scoped the work, Plan had written the requirements, Build had shipped a diff that matched the plan exactly. I trusted that the chain held. I had never actually checked. Then I ran the Review phase, and checking turned out to mean something specific: not does this work, but does this requirement hold up, and what is my evidence. I went in expecting to approve it or send it back. The phase gave me three answers instead: covered, partial, missing. I found out what they meant one requirement at a time, starting with the one I almost got wrong. I had been giving impressions, not verdicts The notification scheduler used a queue to manage dispatch. Every call to the external provider went through it. The provider was never exposed directly. The requirement said the provider must be notified. It was notified, exactly the way I had pictured it. I almost called it covered and moved to the next line. The Review phase stopped me there. But the requirement said must be notified , not how. The queue had introduced a call order and a timing the requirement never anticipated. Nothing was broken. Something had changed shape, quietly, and nobody had written that shape down. I sat with that for longer than I expected to. Not because the code was wrong. Because I could not immediately tell you whether the change mattered. The same pass gave the shim from Plan a different verdict on the same page: covered. Mapped to the requirement it existed to satisfy, no gap between what was promised and what was in the diff. One requirement held exactly the shape it was given. The other had quietly grown a new one. Same review. Same pass. Two verdicts. Partial is not a softer word for broken. It is the verdict for