The Prompt Quality Report: What 1,000 Scored Prompts Reveal
Quick answer: The PromptEval Prompt Quality Report scored over 1,000 real prompts across 12 use cases. The average was 52 out of 100, and only 8% reached "good" (75+). The strongest single predictor of a good prompt is whether it defines its output format, worth 27 points on average. In 9 of 10 prompts, the weakest dimension was robustness. This is the PromptEval Prompt Quality Report . Over 1,000 real prompts have been scored on PromptEval , submitted by real users across use cases from customer support to healthcare to code. Each was scored from 0 to 100 on four structural dimensions: clarity, specificity, structure, and robustness. Every figure below comes from that set. No prompt text is stored; the analysis is anonymous and aggregate. Only 8% of the 1,000+ scored prompts reached "good" (75 or higher). Fewer than 1% reached "excellent." Source: PromptEval Prompt Quality Report, 2026 How the scores break down Here is how the scores spread across the set. The bar for "good" is 75, the point where a prompt is clear, specified, and holds up under variation. Score range Share of prompts 0 to 40 (failing) 25% 41 to 60 (below par) 31% 61 to 74 (functional but mediocre) 36% 75 to 84 (good) 8% 85 to 100 (excellent) under 1% Roughly 92% of prompts never reach "good," and almost none reach "excellent." This includes prompts from people who clearly know the tools. The gap is not talent. It is a few missing pieces that repeat. What separates a good prompt from a bad one For each structural element, we compared the average score of prompts that had it against those that did not. These are averages across the set, not a controlled experiment, so read them as correlation. But the gaps were large and consistent. The prompt... Avg with Avg without Point gap Defines the output format 58 31 +27 Has explicit constraints (what not to do) 63 41 +22 Assigns a role or persona 57 42 +15 Includes at least one example 64 51 +13 Prompts that define their output format score 27 points higher