Garry Tan Was Right: "MCP Sucks Honestly." I Have the Token Receipts.
Garry Tan Was Right: "MCP Sucks Honestly." I Have the Token Receipts. "MCP sucks honestly. Context window eats too much, auth is a mess. I wrote a CLI wrapper in 30 minutes and it works better." When YC's CEO says this on X, people listen. But nobody had the data to back it up. Until now. What Garry Tan, Perplexity's CTO, and 97 Million Downloads Can't Hide Three things happened in the last 6 months that changed how I think about MCP: Peter Steinberger (OpenClaw founder) tweeted: "mcp were a mistake. bash is better." Eric Holmes wrote "MCP is dead. Long live the CLI" — it hit HN frontpage Denis Yarats (Perplexity CTO) publicly announced they're replacing MCP with REST API + CLI internally Garry Tan (YC CEO) replied: "MCP sucks honestly" The community split into two camps: "MCP is dead" — CLI is simpler, cheaper, faster "MCP is fine" — 97M downloads, 17K servers, it's the standard Both are wrong. The problem isn't MCP. The problem is what MCP does to your context window. The 47,000-Token Problem Nobody Measured I connected 10 MCP servers to a token counter. Here's what I found: MCP Server Tools Token Cost Equivalent Sequential Thinking 3 890 This blog post Brave Search 8 2,103 A short email Filesystem 11 3,847 A README Memory 9 2,567 A meeting note Puppeteer 15 5,890 A chapter of a book Postgres 19 8,231 A whitepaper GitHub 28 12,440 A court filing Notion 24 13,780 A legal contract Slack 22 14,672 A novella chapter Google Drive 31 47,293 Half of a novel Total 170 111,713 A short book One MCP server — Google Drive — injects 47,293 tokens into your context before you ask a single question. The entire works of Shakespeare is 900K tokens. Google Drive's schema is 5% of Shakespeare. For listing files. The Cost Breakdown (So You Can Get Angry Too) At Claude 3.5 Sonnet pricing ($3/M input tokens, $15/M output): Scenario Tokens Cost Annual Cost 1 server (minimal) 3,847 $0.01/conv $4.40/yr 3 servers (common) 14,528 $0.04/conv $19.40/yr 5 servers (typical) 33,061 $0.10/conv $4