The .gitleaks-baseline.json That Suppressed Live Production Secrets

Originally published at woitzik.dev A previous article here covered setting up gitleaks for homelab secret scanning - the setup, the pre-commit hook, getting CI to fail on new commits that contain secrets. The setup was correct. The tool was running. The CI was green. And it had been quietly suppressing a live production credential for months. This is the follow-on story: not about getting gitleaks running, but about the specific way a baseline file breaks the guarantees you think you have once it's in place. View the complete homelab infrastructure source on GitHub 🐙 What a Baseline File Does (and Is Supposed to Do) When gitleaks first runs on an existing repo, it finds every secret-shaped string in the full git history - including secrets that were introduced years ago, rotated long since, and are completely inert. Flagging those in CI creates noise that causes developers to tune out gitleaks entirely, which is worse than not having it. The baseline workflow is the standard answer: run gitleaks on the current state, export all findings to a JSON file, commit that file to the repo, and tell gitleaks to suppress any finding that already appears in the baseline. Future commits that introduce new secrets still fail; old known-inert findings don't. # Generate baseline from current HEAD gitleaks detect --report-format json --report-path .gitleaks-baseline.json # Tell gitleaks to use it gitleaks detect --baseline-path .gitleaks-baseline.json The assumption embedded in this workflow: findings that appear in the baseline are inert. They were there before the baseline was generated; they've been there; they're known. The Assumption That Broke It The baseline was generated at a point when the repo contained Garage's rpc_secret and admin_token committed in a YAML file. Those were real production values - the cluster was live, using those exact secrets - but the baseline suppression treated them as "known, reviewed, not a problem." The commit that introduced them had happened